Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"A Dead Ringer"
by Scott Mantz

"The Ring"
Naomi Watts, Martin Henderson
Directed by Gore Verbinski

Death, Lies, and Videotape! Naomi Watts gets her hands on a killer video in "The Ring"

Trick or treat, fellow movie lovers! Halloween is finally here, and what better way to "ring" in the spookiest night of the year than with a movie that will scare you right out of your seat? For the better part of the first hour, "The Ring" does just that, thanks to some moody direction and cheap, but effective scare tactics, but before long it falls apart into a ridiculous, confusing mess that just doesn't make any sense.

A mysterious videocassette filled with nightmarish images is making the rounds in the Seattle area, killing those who have seen it within a week. When newspaper reporter Rachel Keller's (Naomi Watts) niece is inexplicably found dead after viewing the tape, she uses her investigative skills to unlock the mystery and maybe even turn it into a story. After watching the tape herself, she finds herself on the other end of an ominous phone call telling her that she has 7 days left to live. Now Rachel's deadline has taken on life-threatening proportions, but the stakes are raised even higher when her 6-year-old son (David Dorfman) also becomes cursed by the deadly video.

The 1998 horror film "Ringu" may have been a phenomenon in Japan (spawning a feature franchise and a television series), but writer Ehren Kruger ("Arlington Road," "Scream 3") and director Gore Verbinski ("Mouse Hunt," "The Mexican") seemed to have missed the boat with this American remake. Sure, there are plenty of spooks and thrills, but for the most part, the film feels contrived, wildly uneven and way too derivative of modern horror classics like "Seven," "Scream," and "The Blair Witch Project." Heck, there's even a creepy kid who looks like he stepped right out of "The Sixth Sense."

After spending the better part of the last decade supporting obscure films like "Tank Girl" and "Dangerous Beauty," Naomi Watts finally took the high road with a remarkable performance in last year's mind-trip "Mulholland Drive." Though the material here doesn't give her nearly as much to work with, she still remains effective enough to stand out in an otherwise mediocre film. The same can't be said about Martin Henderson, who's a relative non-presence as Watts' scruffy, floppy-haired ex who also finds his clock ticking after watching the tape.

Just when you think "The Ring" is going to end, it keeps on going with a ludicrous "surprise" ending that even leaves room for (heaven forbid) a sequel. That may be good news for moviegoers who will likely get caught up in the moment and be scared enough to overlook its flaws, but after the novelty wears off, I suspect that this so-called Halloween treat will be seen as the bad trick that it is.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Scott's Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.