Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"'Dog' Doo" by Scott Mantz

"Dog Park"
Luke Wilson, Natasha Henstridge
Directed by Bruce McCulloch

There are three unbearable situations that I'd hate to be in. The first is having my car break down on the backstreets of North Philadelphia. The second is being on a rowboat in the middle of a hurricane. Finally, the third is being a single guy in the 90's (which I am). It's a bloody take-no-prisoners battleground out there in the dating world. It's hard enough to meet women as it is, but the craziness of the world today makes people so paranoid. You can forget about walking up to a complete stranger and introducing yourself. Blind dates suck, and meeting quality people at a bar just doesn't happen (trust me, I know!). Which is why I just couldn't buy the storyline in "Dog Park". Unrealistic and poorly written, I wouldn't even bother waiting for cable.

Andy (Luke Wilson) and Lorna (Natasha Henstridge) are both distraught over failed relationships when they meet at a bar (oh, please!) and go back to her place (I said, "Oh, please!"). They bond in some screwed-up way, but she blows him off when he sends her roses. Andy confides in Jeri (Janeane Garofalo) and Jeff (Bruce McCulloch), who may seem like a too-cute couple, but there's obviously something beneath the surface. Half the action takes place at the local park, where everyone takes solace in walking their dogs. Both Andy and Lorna date other people before they get their act together and realize they're right for each other.

Too many things occur at the outset that loses me for the rest of the film. First, Andy and Lorna are depressed over relationships with people who were outrageously wrong for them. Second, an attractive woman like Lorna giving a loser like Andy a smile at a bar just doesn't happen (trust me, I know!). Also, the last time I went to a singles bar (just the other day), it was overly crowded with a guy-to-girl ratio of 10-to-1 (in LA, we call this a "dude ranch"). This place was dead. Where was everybody?

I can't buy Luke Wilson as a single loser. You can dress him up as a geek with a boring job, but he's just too good-looking to fit the part. His performance is so uninspired, he must either realize how bad the dialogue is or he just doesn't know what dating is really like (maybe he should just try acting!). It's nice to see Henstridge in a film where she doesn't have to take her clothes off, but even her decent performance can't save the film.

There are two saving graces that keep "Park" from being a total dog. Every film should have an insurance clause to cast Janeane Garofalo. Her sarcastically wise delivery is so authoritative, you'd think she really does have all the answers, at lease until her own life turns upside down. However, let's not forget about the dogs! Now, there's some inspired casting with excellent performances to boot! The scenes with the sweet-but-sensitive pet psychologist are the funniest in the film, but too bad they couldn't make a whole movie out of that. Woof!

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.