Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"'Superstar' Dimly Lit"
by Scott Mantz

"Superstar"
Molly Shannon, Will Ferrell
Directed by Bruce McCulloch

You've got to admire producer Lorne Michaels. His "Saturday Night Live" is celebrating it's 25th anniversary and is one of the longest running shows in television history. Even when it was at its creative worst, he always found ways to reinvigorate the show with fresh talent and funny skits. However, when it comes to his movie career, he must be living by the saying "If you throw enough crap against the wall, some of it's gonna stick". Fortunately, some of it has. "The Blues Brothers" and "Wayne's World" were phenominal successes, but for every "Wayne's World" there have been about ten "It's Pat"'s.

Michaels returns to the SNL skit-cannon to mercilessly stretch out another so-so skit into a 90 minute film. The result is not as bad as you'd expect. While Mary Katherine Gallagher is no Wayne or Elwood Blues, her "Superstar" contains a few good laughs and an optimitsic spirit that makes it worth your while (if you've got nothing better to do and you see it as a matinee!).

Uptight and nerdy Catholic schoolgirl Mary Katherine Gallagher (Molly Shannon) lives her life in a fantasy. Growing up influenced by the pop culture generation, she's convinced that nothing is more important than being a superstar. She's not very popular in school, so she can only dream about sharing a passionate kiss with the oh-so-popular big man on campus (Will Ferrell). Since he's already dating the hottest (and bitchiest) girl in school, Mary Katherine decides to enter the school talent contest to impress her man and win the grand prize--a trip to Hollywood where she can be an extra in a film with "positive moral values".

There are some pretty goofy moments here, but the movie looks like it was just thrown together as a quickie to capitalize on SNL's anniversary. On three seperate occasions I noticed the boom mike visible at the top of the screen, and the special effects (yes, there are special effects in this film) are sloppy. But I digress. These are minor quibbles, and since this is not a Scorsese movie, who really cares? All we're looking for is a few good laughs. While there are a some, most of the humor is the same old slapstick we've seen before.

The biggest strength, of course, is Molly Shannon, who does a decent job of making Mary Katherine seem pathetic and sympathetic at the same time. When you're not laughing at her as she makes a fool out of herself, you're actually rooting for her. She has real dreams, and there's no reason why she can't go for it all. Will Ferrell is mildly funny as the target of her obsession, but when his character takes on biblical proportions in Mary's dreams, he comes up short and and the jokes fall flat.

I dread what's up Michael's sleeve for his next SNL skit-turned movie ("Driving Miss Toonces" maybe?). Call me crazy, but I actually found something positive in "Superstar". For anyone under 30, there's more here than meets the eye. Since the very fabric of our generation has been based on what we've seen on TV, it makes perfect sense that working in Hollywood would seem glamorous (until you've actually done it). With only a few select friends to turn to in times of need, who can blame Gallagher for turning inward and setting her sights on the stars? Her passion and drive to be all that she can be is truly admirable and makes her star shine above the rest.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.