Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"A 'Room' With a View"
by Scott Mantz

"Boiler Room"
Giovanni Ribisi, Ben Affleck
Directed by Ben Younger

In the Hollywood farce "The Player", Tim Robbins plays a hotshot studio executive who decides what movies he's going to make based on pitch meetings he has with writers, producers, and directors. In the opening scene, a couple of writers sum up their film idea as "Out of Africa" meets "Pretty Woman", while another hopeful director describes his premise as "Ghost" meets "The Manchurian Candidate". It's an amusing scene, but it still clearly sums up the creative mindset of today's studio system. Since Hollywood is obviously starving for original ideas, why not pay homage to the best of what's already been done? That's certainly the case with "Boiler Room". While it makes no effort to hide it's inspiration (or should I say imitation) from 'Wall Street" and "Glengarry Glen Ross", it still works as a surprisingly hip, fast-paced, and adrenaline charged film.

Seth Davis (Giovanni Ribisi) is a streetwise college dropout who, much to the chagrin of his demanding judge-father, makes a decent living running an illegal casino out of his apartment. He knows he can't keep it going forever, so when opportunity knocks (literally), he answers the door. He attends a recruitment seminar for a sleazy Long Island brokerage house called J.T. Marlin and becomes seduced by what they have to offer. All he has to do is follow the rules, play the game, and stay on his toes, and within a year, he'll be a millionaire (sorry Regis!). What he doesn't realize is that he'll be selling securities for companies that don't exist. Will he get out in time to save his soul and redeem himself for his father, or will he go down with the ship and drag his father along with him?

"Boiler Room" is not so much a rip-off of "Wall Street" and "Glengarry Glen Ross" as it is more like the birthchild of those films. "Wall Street" came out in 1987 and defined the "greed is good" mentality that defined the 80's. By contrast, "Glengarry" told the plight of the working man down to the "whatever it takes" attitude needed to close the deal. "Boiler Room" takes the best of both films, but it shows how these young hotshots were seduced merely by playing the game--not at what the game was all about. In one scene, Seth and his cohorts are sitting around watching "Wall Street", reciting the dialogue word-for-word. In another scene, Seth is asked if he'd ever seen "Glengarry" to understand what it means to "always be closing". It's all intoxicating, but as Seth finally learns, it's all for nothing.

Giovanni Ribisi is no Matt Damon, but considering it's his first headlining role, he does just fine. He portrays Seth as a survivor, although his methods of survival may leave a lot to be desired. The story builds to a fever pitch, and he realizes that everything he has done has been in an effort to please his father (played with unforgiving coldness by Ron Rifkin). Ribisi's breakdown is intense and devastating, but at least it snaps him back into reality so he can do the right thing.

As for the impressive supporting players, Nicky Katt plays Ribisi's mentor with vicious envy. He's jealous of Ribisi's ambitions, particularly when it comes to his interest in Nia Long, J.T. Marlin's sexpot receptionist. Vin Diesel plays a scrupulous and intimidating power broker, but he shows a shred of reason beneath his cool and cocky exterior. Then there's Ben Affleck, who shows up from time to time as J.T. Marlin's arrogant job recruiter. He's basically playing the same role that Alec Baldwin made famous in "Glengarry Glen Ross", but he makes the role his own and bursts with energy and charisma. However, considering his brief amount of screen time, he probably didn't work on the film for more than a day.

This is nothing that we haven't seen before, but then again, neither was "Three Kings". That film was basically "Kelly's Heroes" set against the backdrop of the Gulf War, but that's OK. Like that film, "Boiler Room" takes a fresh approach that keeps you connected to the story and the characters. It moves along at such an even pace that the time flies by. A watched pot may never boil, but this is one film that boils over the rim with high intensity until it finally reaches its inevitable conclusion.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.