Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"'Mission' Impossible"
by Scott Mantz

"Mission to Mars"
Gary Sinise, Don Cheadle
Directed by Brian DePalma

The summer movie season officially begins with the long Memorial Day Weekend, but lately that seems to be changing. In recent years, the studios started releasing their summer popcorn flicks in the weeks preceding the big weekend, and it is a change in policy that seems to be paying off. Witness Warner Bros, which in 1996 released "Twister" two full weeks before the big summer kickoff. Obviously, it worked, and "Twister" swept up a whopping $241 million at the box office. Last year, "The Mummy" was released as early as May 1 to lackluster reviews. It didn't matter, and it went on to scare up $155 million for Universal.

With most of the country still in a deep freeze, March was an unlikely time for Touchstone to break out "Mission to Mars". Here's one picture that promised what most summer flicks aim for--action, suspense, and cool special effects. Well, one out of three ain't bad. Plagued by a shoddy script, slow pacing, and marginal acting, director Brian DePalma continues his losing streak ("Snake Eyes" anyone?) with a mission that should have been aborted long before it ever got off the ground.

When the first manned mission to Mars ends in disaster, a recovery mission is sent to the red planet to determine the cause and look for survivors. Upon their arrival, mission commander Woody Blake (Tim Robbins) and his crew run into problems of their own. They find the abandoned site of the first mission, where commander Luke Graham (Don Cheadle) has been marooned for a year. Luke tells them that a huge artifact left over by an ancient civilization killed his crew, which is of particular interest to Jim McConnell (Gary Sinise). Upon investigation of the giant artifact, the astronauts discover the origins of life on Mars--and on Earth.

Just because a movie is slow, it doesn't mean it's bad. For example, Stanley Kubrick's "The Shining" was slow, but in an intense way. Terrence Malick's "The Thin Red Line" was slow, but that only added to the poetic feel of the film. Now there's "Mission to Mars" which is slow as in just plain ol' slow. That's unfortunate, because if there's any film that should be filled with dramatic intensity, it's this. The pacing is drawn out, and elements that could have provided plenty of thrills, such as the landing onto the Martian surface, are never even explored.

Product placement is nothing new to the movie business, but this is downright ridiculous! Did we really need to see the "Penzoil" logo on the side of the Mars lander? When Gary Sinise figures out what the Martian message is, he flashes back to Jerry O'Connell playing with his M&M's. Sinise practically poses next to his futuristic Isuzu Trooper, and just when you think you've seen it all, the Dr. Pepper logo is emblazoned on all the drink packets (I half-expected Tim Robbins to turn to the audience and start pitching Dr. Pepper as the official drink for bogus astronauts!).

Considering all the possibilities with science fiction, it's a shame that "Mission to Mars" so blatantly derives elements from so many other films. The discovery of the message from the Martian artifact recalls "Contact" and "Star Trek: The Motion Picture". The climax takes elements from pure-bred films like "2001: A Space Odyssey" and "Close Encounters of the Third Kind" and combines them into one ugly mutt of an ending. I think I'd have more fun simply by reading the back covers of the movie boxes at the video store.

There aren't any real noteworthy performances here, but with a film like this, what do you expect? When accomplished actors Gary Sinise and Don Cheadle aren't looking pensive at the events surrounding them, they're suffering (as are we) with the worst dialogue imaginable. Tim Robbins and Connie Nelson spend far too much time smooching instead of focusing on the mission (get a room, will ya?), which makes the film feel like a Jerry Bruckheimer production, but without the thrills. Jerry O'Connell provides some comic relief, but even he gets a measly three good laughs to his credit.

Over the past year, NASA has had two missions to Mars end in failure. With the fate of the entire Mars program hanging in the balance, it's up to Hollywood to deliver the goods and maybe even provide some goodwill in the process. Well you can count "Mission to Mars" as Hollywood's first failure. Let's hope the November release of Warner Bros. "Red Planet" doesn't bring that up to two.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.