Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"'Glory' Daze"
by Scott Mantz

"The Price of Glory"
Jimmy Smits, Jon Seda
Directed by Carlos Avila

In his classic poem "The Road Not Traveled", Robert Frost examined the significance of approaching a fork in the road and comparing it to the choices we have to make in our everyday lives. Making an important decision is often marred by speculation later on about what might have been if things had been different. That speculation can sometimes lead to reliving the past through our kids. When that happens, it's important to determine that what we're doing is what's best for them, not what's best for us. In other words, don't be selfish. In "The Price of Glory", Jimmy Smits tries so hard to recapture the past that he pays the ultimate price. While the film is filled with strong performances and examines many ethical and moral issues, it ends up being far too contrived and predictable (and long) to leave any lasting emotional impact.

Arturo Ortega (Jimmy Smits) is a former middleweight boxing contender who's best days are behind him. When not one, but all three of his sons begin to show promise in the ring, he sees a second chance to recapture the past. His oldest is Sonny (Jon Seda), a promising fighter who's more concerned with raising a family than spending his life in the ring. There's Jimmy (Clifton Collins Jr.), the stubborn middle brother who can't seem to do right by his even more stubborn father. Finally, there's teenager Johnny (Ernesto Hernandez), who's just waiting in the wings to become the biggest boxer of them all. As the "Fighting Ortegas" move up the ladder, Arturo tightens his grip and oversteps his boundaries as their manager and trainer. Where he was once crucial to their development, he now threatens to hold them back from the big time.

For a film that strives to say so much, "The Price of Glory" ends up saying surprisingly so little. Instead of spending so much time focusing on the same old boxing techniques that we've seen before in countless other films, perhaps more time should have been spent on the values of this closely knit Mexican-American family. With a running time of close to 2 hours, certain scenes tend to drag on and outstay their welcome. Some of those scenes, while emotional and powerfully acted in their own right, feel far too contrived and cliched to really ring true.

Despite the shortcomings of the script, Jimmy Smits is still a commanding presence and does his best with what he is given. He is a man with broken dreams who clearly loves his family, but he winds up using them as a means to an end to nurse old wounds. This leads to plenty of internal conflicts, but after a while, you expect him to wake up and smell the coffee. Even after he makes the ultimate sacrifice, he still doesn't quite get it. When he finally comes through by the film's predictable climax, it's hard to be happy for him. He takes far too long and makes too many sacrifices before he finally realizes what he should have known all along.

As the boxing siblings, all three actors put in convincing performances. John Seda and Clifton Collins Jr. are strong (in more ways than one) as they struggle to overcome their contestants and their father at the same time. Ernesto Hernandez clearly has the best head on his shoulders as the youngest of the three, and Maria del Mar is decent as the supportive and strong mother and wife. Ron Perlman effortlessly displays all the sleazy characteristics that go along with being a boxing promoter, but in the end you realize that he's not such a bad guy after all.

There are a few powerful scenes (which I can't tell you about) and the film pushes all the right emotional buttons. Still, I demand a rematch. It feels too much like a missed opportunity. Perhaps screenwriter Phil Berger and director Carlos Avila will look back at the road not traveled and realize that they delivered a sucker punch instead of a full-blown knockout.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.