Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"'Shanghai' Surprise"
by Scott Mantz

"Shanghai Noon"
Jackie Chan, Owen Wilson
Directed by Tom Dey

"Butch Cassidy and the Sundance Kid" was more than just a great film. It was the birth of an era--the "buddy flick" era, that is. Over the years, Hollywood has had tremendous success toying around with the genre, ranging from Eastwood and Bridges in "Thunderbolt and Lightfoot" to Sarandon and Davis in "Thelma and Louise." What it comes down to is having a charismatic pair and a good story to keep it fresh, which is certainly one way to describe the paring of hyperactive funnyman Chris Tucker with martial-arts action superstar Jackie Chan in "Rush Hour." That film went on to become a huge success in 1998, so it's no surprise that Chan would choose to replicate the formula with Owen Wilson in the hilarious and action-packed "Shanghai Noon."

It's 1881, and Princess Pei Pei (Lucy Liu) has been kidnapped from China's Forbidden City. The Emperor dispatches 3 Imperial Guards to Nevada to get her back, but a fourth, Chon Wang (Jackie Chan), goes along for the ride. To say that he doesn't fit in with the rough and tumble lifestyle of the old west would be a tremendous understatement, but outlaw Roy O' Bannon (Owen Wilson) decides to help when he finds there's a ransom containing gold. O'Bannon winds up doing more harm than good, and he and Wang try to stay one step ahead of O'Bannon's old gang of train robbers and a corrupt sheriff from Carson City (Xander Berkeley).

After making his name in hoards of Asian action vehicles that bore his name, Jackie Chan has been very smart with his American-produced films. In "Rush Hour," language and cultural barriers only made Chan and Chris Tucker compliment each other even more. Chan could easily have opted to make his second American-produced film a solo vehicle, but he wisely chose to have more fun pairing off with a US co-star. Judging by the results of the finished product, it was a wise move. The cultural trappings add more fun to the banter between Chan and Wilson, and they make for an immensely appealing dynamic duo.

In addition to his incredible martial arts skills, Chan also proves to be a master at comedic timing. His innocent sensibility is a nice match to his physical talent, keeping him as vulnerable as he is powerful. That's where Wilson comes in. He looks like he'd be more at home surfing the open seas than riding the open range. He's so caught up with the image of being an outlaw that he doesn't realize that he's just not good at it. After appearing in commercial films with underwritten roles in "Armageddon" and "The Haunting," Wilson finally gets a chance to shine in a breakout performance. He's so dim-witted and charming that you can't help but like him.

After appearing as a character actor in tons of films ("Apollo 13," "Heat," "Leaving Las Vegas"), Xander Berkeley seems to be having fun as the mean-spirited Carson City sheriff out to get Chan and Wilson. He plays up the western baddie cliche´s, resulting in the type of bad guy that you love to hate. "Ally McBeal's" Lucy Liu is incredibly beautiful as Princess Pei Pei, but it's an underwritten role that doesn't give her much to work with until she displays some martial arts of her own. Finally, Lo Fong is decent as the evil ex-imperial guard responsible for Liu's abduction.

The buddy flick gets a new twist when the old east meets the old west, and it's an exciting and often funny trip to take. Jackie Chan continues his domination of the American film market, and Owen Wilson finally gets the right commercial vehicle to display his appealing and comedic acting chops. If you're looking for a fresh and funny film that plays with buddy-flick and cowboy stereotypes, then "Shanghai Noon" is a nice surprise.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.