Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"'DeMented' Forever"
by Scott Mantz

"Cecil B. DeMented"
Melanie Griffith, Stephen
Dorff Directed by John Waters

Ever since the release of his trashy cinematic classic "Pink Flamingos" in 1974, director John Waters has been notorious for making films outside the Hollywood studio system. Though he's never quite had a mainstream hit, he's maintained a loyal and devoted legion of fans who continue to embrace his trashy and twisted cinematic style. With his latest release, Waters sends up the very industry in which he has made his name, and while "Cecil B DeMented" certainly has its moments of zany hysteria, it is unlikely that it will find an audience outside Water's circle of fans. Then again, who's complaining?

Hollywood screen diva Honey Whitlock (Melanie Griffith) is in Baltimore to promote the release of her latest film "Some Kind of Happiness." In front of a stunned audience at the black-tie premiere, she is kidnapped by a group of guerrilla filmmakers, led by the deranged Cecil B. DeMented (Stephen Dorff), who are intent on using her in their film. At first, Honey refuses to comply with their demands, but she gives in when she sees the back-stabbing Hollywood system for what it really is. DeMented, Whitlock, and their band of filmmakers go on a terrorist spree around town all in the name of art, and they are determined to finish their film even if it kills them (or anyone else who gets in their way).

In a summer filled with giant hamsters shooting projectile turds, killer dildos, and live chickens stuck up people's rectal areas, some people would argue that John Water's type of trashy humor has gone out of style. On the other hand, where would the Farrelly brothers, those reigning kings of gross-out comedy, be had it not been for Divine's stomach-churning feast at the climax of "Pink Flamingos?" Waters may not always come through, but there's no doubt that his best films, especially "Hairspray," "Polyester," "Cry Baby," and 1998's underrated "Pecker," hit their mark for their sheer no-holds-barred look at white trash suburbia.

"Cecil B. DeMented" is more of the same for Waters. Even though he once again uses his home town of Baltimore for his setting, he may just as well have shot the film right in the heart of Hollywood. Actually, shot through the heart is more like it. Waters pulls no punches in his disdain for mainstream filmmaking, with the film's biggest jokes coming at the expense of notorious director's cuts, lame sequels, and English dubbing of foreign films. But it's the more inside jokes at the expense of the Screen Actor's Guild and MPAA President Jack Valente that may fall on deaf ears.

Mainstream Hollywood takes a real beating, but the independent scene doesn't get off so easily either. Stephen Dorff is perfectly cast as the enthusiastic filmmaker who will stop at nothing to get his film made, which is undoubtedly a nudge to obsessive filmmakers who have yet to learn that it's only a movie. Melanie Griffith has not made the best career choices lately ("Crazy in Alabama" anyone? Ugh!), but she digs deep into her role as a screen diva who becomes victim to the Patty Hearst-style kidnapping. Maybe it's just a case of art imitating life, but it's still fun to watch Griffith poke fun at her own image.

"Cecil B. DeMented" may tear apart the whole guerrilla filmmaking mentality as much as it pays homage to it, but Steve Martin and Eddie Murphy covered similar ground with better results in last year's "Bowfinger." In that sense, "Cecil B. DeMented" comes across as "Bowfinger" on acid. The film makes it point early on, but after the first 20 minutes, the jokes become repetitive, and the film falls apart into a mess of mass confusion. There's enough zaniness, craziness, and trashiness going on to ensure its cult status in the John Waters film canon, but if this particular style doesn't do anything for you, neither will the film.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Scott's Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.