Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"'Double' Take"
by Scott Mantz

"Double Jeopardy"
Ashley Judd, Tommy Lee Jones
Directed by Bruce Beresford

Ok, here's the pitch. Our main protagonist is framed for a murder she didn't commit. After serving jail time, she gets out and is obsessed with setting the record straight and clearing her name. As she embarks on her mission, we'll need somebody with a commanding screen presence--oh, let's say a Tommy-Lee-Jones-type--to catch her and bring her in.

Oh, waitaminute. That does sound familiar. You're right. It was done before back in 1993 with "The Fugitive", which--surprise, surprise--co-starred Tommy Lee Jones. With a too-similar premise and a trailer that showed just a little too much, you can pretty much guess where this story is going, right? Well, not exactly. A decent performance from Ashley Judd and some nifty plot twists make the suspenseful "Double Jeopardy" a fun watch, but that's about all it is.

Libby Parsons (Ashley Judd) is living the good life with her rich husband Nick (Peter Greenwood) and adorable son. She's got it all, that is, until she wakes up on a boat to find herself covered in what appears to be her husband's blood. She's literally caught with the knife in her hand, and all the evidence points to her guilt. During her 6 year prison term, she discovers that, holy moly, Nick faked his death to dodge embezzlement charges. What's a girl to do? A fellow jailbird, who used to be an attorney (how convenient), informs her about the "double jeopardy" clause, which states that you can't be tried for the same crime twice. She plots her revenge, and upon her release is put in the custody of a parole officer (Tommy Lee Jones). Libby skips bail to find Nick and get her son back, and it's up to him to bring her in.

There's just one minor problem with which the premise for the entire movie hinges, which is you cannot be tried for the same crime twice. According to attorney Alan Dershowitz, you can be tried twice if the crimes take place in different locales. Ah, the heck with that minor tidbit! Let's just enjoy the film!

It's a little ironic that Jones gets top billing over Judd. She's in every scene, and he doesn't appear until almost 40 minutes into the film. In her biggest role to date, Judd puts in a convincing performance as the scorned woman who just wants her son back. She may be obsessed, but she's not crazy. Thankfully, we're able to stay with her and root for her as she obtains what is rightfully hers.

Jones is the real mystery here. He may be playing a down-on-his-luck parole officer, but all we're seeing is a toned down version of his Academy Award-winning role from "The Fugitive". Jones, having suffered the loss of his own daughter, shares Judd's grief for her son. Instead of looking deeper into that, we're seeing the same slick "just-missed-her" pursuit that we've seen before. Peter Greenwood gets high marks for jumping from the loving sweetie-pie to the corrupt loser he turns out to be.

It feels like there's just not enough energy to support the film. In the finale, Libby should be furious when she confronts Nick, but she remains a little too calm. The payoff is not strong and doesn't justify the buildup. Minor plot twists keep the film fresh, but not fresh enough to feel the jeopardy of our heroine.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.