Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"This 'Muse' Doesn't Amuse"
by Scott Mantz

"The Muse"
Albert Brooks, Sharon Stone,
Andie MacDowell
Directed by Albert Brooks

We live in a time where everyone from California to the New York Islands can talk about what's happening in Tinseltown. Thanks to magazines like "Entertainment Weekly", "Movieline", and "Premiere", as well as TV shows like "Entertainment Tonight" and "Access Hollywood", the discussion at the dinner table can range from "How was your day, Honey" to "Can you believe that 'The Sixth Sense' was number one at the box office again?". In short, show business is everybody's business, and entertainment news is, well, news. Proven by the success of "Bowfinger", movies that make fun of movies are not limited to those who live within 30 miles of the 310 area code.

However, take a show-biz satire and put it in the hands of Albert Brooks, and the result is a much smaller target audience. Let's face it--Brooks, like Woody Allen, is definitely an acquired taste, and even fans of Brooks' sulky, self-pitying humor will not be amused by "The Muse". While we were able to laugh at his self scrutiny during "Lost in America" and "Defending Your Life", here he finally comes across as merely annoying.

Steven Phillips (Albert Brooks) is an award-winning screenwriter who's best days are behind him. When he gets fired from Paramount for losing his "edge", he goes to his successful screenwriter-friend (Jeff Bridges) for advice. He tells Steven about Sarah (Sharon Stone), a descendant of Zeus, or a Muse, who helped inspire his creativity. Steven pleads with Sarah to help him get his "edge" back. She'll help, but he will have to be at her beckoning call 24 hours a day and adhere to her very lengthy, and very expensive, demands.

It's hard to feel sorry for Steven. Even though his concerns about providing for his family are real, he becomes less sympathetic when Sarah helps his wife Laura (Andie MacDowell) start a successful cookie business. The threat is gone now that money is coming in, but Steven becomes jealous and self-absorbed (hey, that's Hollywood!) when he should be happy and grateful that his money problems are over.

Stone finally gets a chance to break free from her serious roles, and it's obvious that she's having fun. She provides some naive charm while still utilizing her demanding screen presence. However, given the material she has to work with, she never gets a chance to really take off with the role. Likewise for MacDowell, who turns in a routine performance as Laura.

"The Muse" has its moments. When Brooks collects a Humanitarian Award at the beginning of he film, his speech is an obvious dig to James Cameron's embarrassing Academy Award acceptance speech for "Titanic". Even more ironic is the cameo Cameron makes, asking Sarah for advice on a sequel to his epic film. In another cameo, Martin Scorcese is so energetic, he could be the next poster boy for Starbuck's Coffee. Other cameos by Rob Reiner, Jennifer Tilly, and Lorenzo Lamas recall amusing scenes from another Hollywood satire, "The Player".

Ultimately, "The Muse" starts out with strong promise, but it doesn't deliver the goods. Certain scenes are merely episodic to provide humor to the film, but even they aren't very funny. It makes you wonder where the Muse was when Brooks was making this movie. Better luck next time.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.