Scott's New Movie Reviews

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

Scott's Rating System

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)

"1999: A Hollywood Odyssey" by Scott Mantz

There's nothing like Hollywood around Chrismastime! While the rest of the country is knee-deep in holiday shopping, snow shoveling, or just plain ol' millennial madness, film critics everywhere are busy compiling their lists for the best and worst of what they saw this year. While certain films are sure to be featured on many lists, some choices are bound to be surprising. Well, to each his own. Remember, we're critics, not experts, and these days, everyone's a critic. So, without further ado, here are my picks for the best of what we, or, at least, I, saw over the last 52 weekends. So, put away your lightsaber, stamp out that cigarette, and get ready to see a lot more than just a few dead people!

1) "The Sixth Sense". What a great story, and I'm not even talking about the script (which, by the way, was also great)! Do you remember all the hype surrounding this summer release? Me neither, and that's precisely the point. Here's a film that was released on its own merits. Instead of the usual situation where a film finds an audience, this was a case where the audience found the film. My initial reaction was that it was good, but the beginning was a little slow. Obviously, the acting was excellent (including an Oscar-worthy performance by young Haley Joel Osment), and the surprise ending was brilliant. Like the rest of the country, I went back and saw it again. Here's a case where the payoff was even better the second time around. Even knowing how it ends, I found myself hanging on every scene to make sure all the clues where there and nothing fell through the cracks. Nothing did. Director M. Night Shyamalan really nailed it.

2) "The Insider". The mere mention of the plot, about a Big Tobacco whistle blower, is enough to make you fall asleep. But just you wait. Writer-director Michael Mann was able to infuse a sharp and witty script with spectacular performances from his lead actors. Russell Crowe's silent breakdown combined with Al Pacino's intense loyalty keeps you on the edge of your seat. This will no doubt be recognized by the Academy come Oscar time. Not since "All the President's Men" has the power of free speech been so documented in a film. In this case, free speech lost. Unfortunately, so did success at the box office.

3) "Three Kings". Not too many movies were based on the Gulf War, and for good reason. Unlike World War II and Vietnam, this was one war that was over before it even started. That left a few soldiers hungry for a little payback. What started as a justification for missing out on all the action turned into a morality play on responsibility and doing what's right. Excellent performances by George Clooney, Mark Whalberg, and Ice Cube are like icing on an already delicious cake, thanks to the innovative direction of David O' Russell. The true message of the film hits you long after you leave the theater and makes you wonder why we even went to Iraq in the first place.

4) "The Iron Giant". This Warner Bros. animated release should have given Disney a run for its money, but it was not to be. Too bad. Grossing a paltry $26 million, this giant is an instant classic. Not since "ET" had a film captured the beauty and the power of a friendship that was much more than skin deep. Director Brad Bird combined the paranoia of the cold war with the lost innocence of the 50's to create a film the whole family can enjoy. If there's any justice, this timeless gem will have along life on video.

5) "American Beauty". Even the title sounds like a winner. Here's a film that took a close look at the American dream and saw nothing there but a bunch of lies. Second chances don't come very often, but Kevin Spacey is ready for his. His liberating and Oscar-caliber performance is filled with all the energy of a man desperate to get his life back even if it kills him (and maybe even get a shot at his teenage daughter's sexy best friend). Newcomer Wes Bentley may seem odd on the surface, but he winds up being the only true character, looking closer at all the little things that make America beautiful.

6) "Being John Malkovich". On the surface this may seem like a commentary about the public's intoxicating obsession with celebrity, but it's actually much more than that. Outrageous characters and an absurd plot make this one of the most entertaining, and definitely the most original, films of the year. John Cusack is the pathetic puppeteer who, along with sexy ice queen Catherine Keener, finds a portal that leads to the head of John Malkovich. That sounds crazy, but the minute you peer through the elevator and look out onto the 7 1/2 floor of an office building, you easily accept what's about to happen. Welcome to Wonderland! Cameron Diaz is unrecognizable as Cusack's pet-loving wife, but Malkovich is the real treat. He may be the first actor to ever get nominated for an Oscar just for playing himself.

7) "The Red Violin". Here's a film where the main star is actually an inanimate object. What's remarkable is how successfully the filmmakers are able to make you feel compassion and sympathy for the cursed violin. Painted in the blood of the deceased manufacturer's wife, the violin gets passed from one tragic circumstance to the next over the course of 300 years. We take the journey on an intellectual and emotional level. While certain vignettes are stronger than others, they all portray the risks that people take for their passion and the tragic consequences that they can lead to. One can't help but wonder what will happen to its final possessor, obsessed instrument restorer Samuel L. Jackson, when he takes the violin home to his daughter for its intended use.

8) "Eyes Wide Shut". I know I'm going to get it for this one! This movie needs to go away for a while before it can truly be appreciated for what it is--a dreamlike tale about fate and karma. Kubrick has never been one to direct easy movies, and this is no exception. There's much more going on than just a story about sexual obsession and jealousy. Nicole Kidman may have given a fiery admission about impure thoughts to her husband Tom Cruise, but she didn't actually do anything wrong. She just thought about it. Even though Cruise's journey takes him from one bizarre situation to the next, he doesn't do anything wrong either. It's almost as if they were meant to stay together and some outside force was testing their will. While it may not be Kubrick's masterpiece, it is a beautiful and haunting piece of brilliance which warrants speculation and interpretation. The same thing can be said about another Kubrick movie--"2001: A Space Odyssey".

9) "October Sky". The "Stand By Me" of the 90's. Living in a depressed coal mining town with strict parents, a young boy dreams about building rockets that may one day take man to the stars. With no big-name leads and excellent supporting turns from Chris Cooper and Laura Dern, this little-seen gem has a powerful and emotional story that stands on its own merits. The schmaltz factor gets a little much, but so what? Never lose your dreams. The only person who will make them a reality is you.

10) "Fight Club". The "American Beauty" for the Gen-X crowd. Corporate business drone Edward Norton has a mid-life crisis while still in his 20's. He and repulsive soap maker Brad Pitt start a club where insensitive males get their feelings back by beating the crap out of each other. Sure, it's violent, but so were the Indiana Jones movies. Shot with the dark and burned-out look of the film's tone, the film eventually reveals itself as something completely different from what you think it is, thanks to the second-best ending of any film this year.

Well, there you have it! There are other films that deserve honorable mention ("Boys Don't Cry", "The Blair Witch Project", "Run Lola Run"), but I only have ten choices. Also, there are a number of movies that haven't even been released yet ("Magnolia", "The Green Mile").

By the way, have we learned anything from all this? Well, yes. The big studios still aren't afraid to take chances. Most of the films listed above took a risky approach that only the Independents usually take. Unfortunately, these noble efforts didn't translate into box office gold. With the exception of "The Sixth Sense", none of these films made back enough money to cover their cost (at least during their domestic release). Hopefully, that won't scare studio heads too much. Let's face it--nobody ever said risk-taking was cheap.

Back to Scott's New Movie Reviews

Review Archives

The Critic
Who is Scott?
(click to find out !)


Creation Home
© Scott Mantz - Scott's Movie Reviews
Unauthorized duplication of graphics or material appearing in this site is prohibited.